• Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 148 other subscribers
  • “Writing, to me, is simply thinking through my fingers” — Isaac Asimov

  • Recent Posts

  • Pages

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Blog Stats

    • 176,676 hits

A Flawed System

Even though I had a good day, I’m feeling the need to vent a bit, so please bear with me.

I would really love to know who came up with an educational system that allows a child to make it to the 9th grade while only being able to read at a second grade level.

I’m not kidding.

I am an intensive reading teacher.

I have students who, for various reasons, cannot comprehend text well.

Their struggles have to do with learning disabilities, lack of a strong vocabulary, little practice in higher order thinking, and difficult home lives that don’t lend themselves to meaningful conversations, which has been proven to affect reading ability.

With that said, my current students are fortunate in that their reading levels are higher than the one described above.  However, I do know of students who fall into this category, so the issue hits close to home.

I am frustrated.


Because instead of doing what’s right for these students, which is to place them in special classes with students their own age and of similar reading ability, these struggling students are placed in mainstream classes.

Adding to the embarrassment of being unable to perform at the same level as their peers, they are described as “lazy” by some teachers.

Perhaps they aren’t lazy.

Perhaps they cannot read the instructions of assignments.

Perhaps the assignments are too overwhelming and need to be broken down into smaller chunks.

Perhaps they need accompanying pictures to help them understand the assignment parameters.

Perhaps these students need to be taught by teachers who are specially trained to balance their social ages with their academic abilities.

While I can sort of understand why students are promoted socially, it doesn’t, in reality, make sense as far as the students’ long-term success goes.

If students are constantly promoted, they’ll eventually graduate…without the ability to read job applications or solve problems by thinking critically.

Who loses out?

Ultimately, and most importantly, it’s the students in need of specialized teaching.

What’s the answer?

I don’t know.

I’m still new at this teaching thing and don’t envision ever transitioning into a position that puts me in charge of making these kinds of decisions.

What I do know is that it is teachers such as myself who are called upon to provide a meaningful education to such struggling students…students who are seven or eight years behind their peers.

It is teachers like myself who are left feeling very inadequate and unsure what interventions to use to best assist these students.

It is teachers like myself who carry guilt with them because they don’t feel that they are adequately serving the needs of ALL of their students.  While teachers are taught to differentiate instruction according to the learning abilities, styles, and personalities of their students, when there is a seven or eight year difference in skills…well…that is a very overwhelming task!

It’s not surprising that the system is flawed.

Most government systems are.


Because one size doesn’t fit all.

Because saving money is more important than doing what needs to be done to ensure that schools produce young adults who can confidently contribute to society.

Because it’s easier to talk the talk than to walk the walk.

Because it’s easier to sit in an office, far removed from a classroom, and make decisions about students who exist solely on paper.

Because it’s easier to make decisions from afar without really seeing the effect they have on those in the classroom.

THAT takes real work…real sacrifice…and I don’t know if the powers-that-be who make such decisions are willing to get down and dirty to do what it will take to fix a flawed system.

2 Responses

  1. The good news is our state (and country) has outlawed what happened to this student – social promotion. The good news is we have procedures i place to get this student the help he needs. The good news is he’s landed at Bay High where people move heaven and earth to do what’s best for kids (God always has a plan!). The good news is he has YOU for a teacher! And finally, the best news is we don’t teach in Jamaica!!!!!!!! 😉

  2. Oh man! Those are definitely some common issues among any state and county. While I start at the lowest possible traditional school setting, I can understand your frustrations and see how this could be very stressful on you. However, I know that if it can be done….you can do it!:) Your students are very lucky to have someone who cares. {hugs} – Tiff♥

Thank you for visiting today and taking the time to leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: